Some quick stats: 160 reviews, 323 credited authors, and 1311 maps. That's roughly 2 authors per review, 8 maps per review, and 4 maps per author. Fun stuff!
And now, the ten most popular pages by pageview, according to Blogger, and my reactions:
Pimped around the Russian community, Sacrament just barely beat out Whitemare, if only because it's been a page longer.
09: Master Levels for Doom II
Like a few others on this list, I have my suspicions that a lot of these page hits are looking for warez, but a fair number were filtered through my anemic Features tab.
08: 1994 Tune-Up Community Project
Still draws a few hits daily.
07: Doom 2 Unleashed (Paul Corfiatis's Community Project)
Same as 1994TU.
06: The Phobos Directive
Dark horse candidate! Very popular review for no reason I can see through search traffic or sources, unless I missed some copious link traffic.
05: Aliens: Colonial Marines TC
Piggybacking hits off of the Colonial Marines property, for the most part, with a few looking for the '94 conversion.
04: Eternal Doom
Half of the search hits I see mentioning Eternal Doom are looking for hints, amusingly enough.
03: Star Wars: Chibi Rebellion
Like Aliens, but a much more blatant case when I see the search hits. I hope a lot of this traffic gets interested enough to download Mouse's excellent Star Wars FPS!
02: Perdition's Gate
One of the oldest posts on the blog. Also, tons of warez hits. I want to get up the gumption to petition Atari to release this as freeware...someday.
01: Hell to Pay
Ditto on every point.